The trades have a labor problem that isn’t going away on its own. Skilled painters, estimators, and crew leads are harder to find every year, and the contractors still hiring only from the same narrow pool they always have are competing for a shrinking group of candidates. The businesses actually solving their staffing gaps are the ones who widened who they’re looking at in the first place.
This isn’t about checking a box. It’s about the math of a tight labor market — and a handful of practical business reasons that show up directly in your bottom line.
You’ve likely felt this firsthand already: a job posting that used to get a dozen solid applicants now gets three, and half of those don’t show up for the interview. That’s not a fluke. It’s the shape of the labor market right now, and it’s not reversing on its own. The contractors adjusting how they hire are the ones filling crews. The ones sticking to the exact same playbook they used five years ago are the ones with the empty seats.
The Labor Pool Is Smaller Than It Used To Be
Every year, fewer people are entering the trades relative to how many are retiring out of them. If your hiring approach only looks at candidates who fit the exact profile of who you’ve always hired, you’re fishing in a pool that’s shrinking every year — while your competitors who’ve opened up their search are pulling from a much bigger one.
That means seriously considering candidates you might not have a few years ago: career changers coming from other industries, veterans with discipline and work ethic but no formal trade background, women entering painting and other trades in growing numbers, and workers from different cultural and language backgrounds who bring skills your current team doesn’t have. None of this is about lowering your standards. It’s about not artificially narrowing your candidate pool when you can least afford to.
Think about the specific candidate your job posting is quietly filtering out right now without you noticing. A posting that assumes prior trade experience, written in language that only makes sense to someone already in the industry, tells a career changer with real potential to keep scrolling. That’s not a standards issue — that’s a wording issue costing you candidates who might’ve been strong hires if the posting had spoken to them at all.
A Broader Team Reaches a Broader Customer Base
If any part of your market includes Spanish-speaking homeowners or property managers, having crew members or office staff who speak the language isn’t a nice-to-have — it’s the difference between winning that estimate and losing it to the contractor down the street who can actually communicate clearly with the customer. The same logic applies to any community your business serves where the standard hiring pool doesn’t reflect who’s actually calling for a quote.
This is a straightforward business calculation, not an abstract value. A crew that can only communicate in one language, in a market where a meaningful share of homeowners speak another, is leaving jobs on the table before the estimate call even happens.
Different Backgrounds Catch Different Problems
A crew or office team built entirely of people with the same background and the same work history tends to solve problems the same way — which is fine until the problem is one none of them have seen before. A team with a wider range of backgrounds and experience brings more ways of looking at the same job-site problem, which matters more than it sounds like when you’re troubleshooting a scheduling conflict, a tricky scope, or a supplier issue nobody’s dealt with before.
This shows up in hiring decisions too. If every person doing your hiring has the same background and the same instincts about what a “good hire” looks like, you’ll keep hiring the same kind of person — and missing good candidates who don’t happen to fit that specific mold but would do the job well.
It Keeps the Team You Already Have
Retention matters as much as hiring, maybe more. Painters and office staff who feel like they’re respected and treated fairly — regardless of background — stick around longer than ones who don’t. That’s not a soft HR talking point. Turnover is expensive: retraining time, lost institutional knowledge, and the gap while a role sits open. A team where people feel valued for the work they do, not judged on anything else, is a team that stays.
This is especially true in a tight labor market. If word gets around that your business treats people fairly regardless of who they are, that reputation becomes a recruiting advantage on its own — candidates hear about it from people already on your crew, and that’s a stronger signal than any job posting.
Word travels fast in the trades. Painters and crew leads talk to each other, across companies and across job sites. A reputation for treating people well — regardless of background, regardless of how long they’ve been in the trade — spreads the same way a reputation for underpaying or overworking a crew does. In a market where good candidates have options, that reputation is doing recruiting work for you before a single job posting goes up.
What This Actually Looks Like for a Contractor
None of this requires a formal program or a corporate initiative. It looks like:
- Widening where you post job openings. If you’re only recruiting through the same networks you always have, you’re seeing the same narrow slice of candidates every time. Post where a broader range of people will actually see it.
- Evaluating candidates on the work, not the résumé shape. A career changer with no formal trade background but strong references and a demonstrated work ethic might outperform someone who checks the traditional boxes but doesn’t actually want the job.
- Making the job posting itself clear and specific. Vague postings attract vague candidates. Specific postings — what the job actually is, what a typical week looks like, what the pay and expectations are — attract people who know exactly what they’re signing up for, regardless of their background.
- Paying attention to how your team treats new hires who don’t look like the rest of the crew. A wider hiring pool doesn’t help if new hires don’t feel like they belong once they’re there. That’s a leadership issue, not a hiring one, and it’s worth watching closely.
The Business Case, Not the Talking Point
Strip away the corporate language, and the reason to widen your hiring net comes down to this: in a labor market this tight, the contractors who limit themselves to the narrowest possible candidate pool are competing hardest for the fewest available people. The ones willing to look past the traditional profile — at career changers, veterans, workers from different backgrounds, candidates who reflect the communities they actually serve — are pulling from a bigger pool and winning more of the hires that matter.
That’s not about optics. It’s about which businesses can actually staff their crews in a market where good people are hard to find, and which ones keep losing candidates to contractors who stopped limiting themselves first.
What to Do Before Your Next Hire
Before you post your next job opening, look back at your last five hires and ask where they came from — the same network, the same background, the same referral chain every time? If so, that’s not a bad thing on its own, but it is a sign your candidate pool is narrower than it needs to be in a market this tight. Widen where you’re looking before you’re desperate to fill the role, not after.
Book a Free 20-Minute Call →
If You’d Rather Hand This Off Entirely — That’s What We Do.
My Virtual Resources handles lead calling, estimate follow-up, and project coordination for painting contractors and home service businesses. No hiring. No training. No overhead.
Book a Free Call →